top of page
Hummingbird on nest

Documentation

Wake Robins - wildflowers

This page has updates on current discoveries about the Park District Staff’s efforts to keep the intensive downhill facility a secret, environmental science as it applies to park design, and emerging issues that are important to Wildcat Canyon Park. It also displays Presentations, References, Letters regarding the proposed project, and Park District Planning Documents.

 

Friends of Wildcat Canyon Park will be posting updates in this space. Currently, we are analyzing over 1400 pages of Public Records Requests from the Park District and will post our results in this space. We have high standards for our reporting and will include direct quotes from these sources when appropriate. Currently, we are interested in a series of conversations between Park District trail staff and the prospective donors.

Planning in secret

Sean Dougan, Trails Program Manager for the Park District, appears to have a conflict of interest between his central role in planning the proposed intensive downhill trail and his activities as first founding donor of the California Mountain Biking Coalition, a political advocacy group. His position is listed as being subject to the Park District’s Conflict of Interest policy, and the most appropriate category is probably “Land use planning review and zoning."

The East Bay Trail Secret Deal podcast: 

PDF: Timeline: Planning in Secret

Park District manipulates Biological Resource Assessment

In 2024, the East Bay Regional Park District engaged Nomad Ecology to carry out a Biological Resources Assessment (BRA) for the area proposed for a project termed the “Wildcat Bike Trail.” When agencies want to build something in a sensitive area, they engage such businesses to conduct independent investigations about the impacts of the project.

​

The Park District recently released the working draft of the BRA with every edit marked by who made it and when. Some of the edits were made by the trail project’s own planner, who is not a biologist. Heath Bartosh, a founder of Nomad Ecology, participated in the process with multiple Park District personnel. Note that a project manager is allowed to comment on a draft, but the edited document was presented to the public as an unbiased biologists’ assessment.

​

A few examples:

​

Deleted, December 30, 2024: a paragraph that said mountain bike trail grades “should never exceed 15%” and should stay under 10% on loamy soils and 5% for fragile soils because steeper trails lose more soil. This is a critical issue for the proposed intensive trail facility because the grade averages 8% and any soil loss will be washed downhill into Wildcat Creek, where the Park District is spending hundreds of thousands of dollars to bring back native rainbow trout and steelhead.

 

Deleted, December 30, 2024: a section under the heading of “Impacts to Habitat,” which began with, “Trail construction can cause habitat fragmentation if not located strategically.” For example, bobcats and mountain lions are keystone predators that may be driven out of an area if trails interfere with places to raise their young or to hunt for food, in which case the ecosystem will collapse.

 

Narrowed, February 3, 2026: a requirement for erosion control “in all areas that could be subject to erosion and sedimentation.” The planner wrote that this was too general.

 

Deleted, February 4, 2026: a requirement that the Park District “routinely patrol the new bike trail” and issue citations to riders who break the rules.

Biological Resources Assessment (BAR)

00:00 / 19:43

Information from trusted sources

Siting criteria for intensive recreational facilities

​The EBRPD does not have Siting Criteria in place for locating intensive recreation facilities such as flow trails. The creation of such guidelines by a public process would create orderly, predictable, and transparent standards for land use issues. California State Parks and San Diego County Parks currently abide by such policies. The Friends of Wildcat Canyon Park has drafted formal siting criteria and presented the document to the EBRPD Board at their May 5, 2026, meeting. 

Friends of Wildcat Canyon Park’s Proposed EBRPD Siting Criteria Policy for Intensive Recreational Activities


Unrealistic project area

​

The Wildcat Bike Trail on the EBRPD website is not accurately illustrated. Only an angular green outline superimposed over a hillside is shown, preventing the EIR and the public from realizing that the proposed trail is in the center of the park. Furthermore, Nomad Ecology’s Biological Resource Assessment limits the project area to the 1.4-mile trail corridor and a narrow buffer, which excludes potential harm to ecologically sensitive areas within the more accurate 4.4-mile circulation loop in the middle of the park.

Non-specific Illustration on EBRPD Website
Circulation map from Pointe Strategies Design for contrast
​

References

Basics of park design with sensitive habitat zones

​

In 2023, the San Francisco Estuary Institute published a booklet entitled, “Ecology for Health. Design Guidance for Fostering Human Health and Biodiversity in Cities.” See summary of Biodiversity Benefits and Human Health Benefits of large parks on page 34. On page 35, the drawing illustrates placement of extremely sensitive habitat zones in areas with limited access, surrounded by transitional buffer spaces. High-use recreational elements are on the periphery, near the urban core. These concepts are not new.

​

Ecology for Health. Design Guidance for Fostering Human Health and Biodiversity in Cities.

​​

​

Fencing

​

The concept of wildlife-friendly fences originated in states like Wyoming and Montana, where cattle ranchers had to make expensive repairs of fencing damaged by migrating elk and antelope (most recent edition, Paige 2025). The second reference (which includes the author who originated the concept) calls for more research on ecosystem effects. The design proposed for Wildcat Canyon Park is outdated and entirely inappropriate for our area because it is not designed to spare nocturnal hunters and winged predators.

​

A Wyoming landowner’s handbook to fences and wildlife: Practical tips for fencing with wildlife in mind

A fence runs through it: A call for greater attention to the influence of fences on wildlife and ecosystems

​

Microplastics

​

This scientific study documents a method that can be used to quantify microplastic abrasion of bicycle tires. Mountain bike tires release microplastics and micro-rubber particles into the environment as they wear down against trails and dirt surfaces. 

Quantifying abrasion of microplastics from mountain bike tires

​Letters of support

Selected “Scoping Comments” submitted by Friends of Wildcat Canyon and others to the EBRPD during the initial stages of preparing an Environmental Impact Report (EIR) under the California Environmental Quality Act, or CEQA.

     

In August 2025, the EBRPD Board voted to prepare an Environmental Impact Report (EIR) for the project called, "Wildcat Bike Trail." The public submitted “Scoping Comments” on whether the specifications for the EIR identified all the important impacts of the project, such as the extent of environmental damage, safety conflicts, and private donor influence. 
Several pertinent scoping letters can be found below:

​​​Friends of Wildcat Canyon Comment Letter

Robert A. Leidy, Ph.D., Ecologist

SPRAWLDEF Comment Letter #1

Villa Mira Vista Homeowners Association

​San Pablo Creeks Watershed Council

UC Berkeley Graduate Professor John Taylor

California Native Plant Society

Golden Gate Bird Alliance

California Urban Streams Partnership

Citizens for Eastshore Parks

California State Horsemen's Association Inc, Region 5 Alameda and Contra Costa 

Regional Parks Association​

Historical Summary Letter 

This letter provides an excellent summary of the issues and their history.

SPRAWLDEF letter 7/20/25​

East Bay Regional Park District Planning Documents

Nomad Ecology Evaluation

Pointe Strategies Trail Design

Pointe Strategies Design Circulation Map

Water Quality and Riparian Trails references

Wildcat Canyon Regional Park Land Use Plan EBRPD 1985

Pointe Strategies Wildcat Bike Trail 2024

Authorization of NOP EIR WCRP Bike Trail EBRPD 2025

National Interscholastic Cycling Association Race results 2025

Environmental Checklist Draft WCRP Bike Trail EBRPD Undated

Jewel Lake Technical Report for EBRPD 2025

State Policy for Water Quality Control 2019 2021

SF Bay Basin Water Quality Control Plan 201​5

​

Photo credits:

Hummingbird in nest - © 2026 LAZY BIRDERS

Wake Robins - © 2026 Craig Noble 

​

bottom of page