top of page
Dark red small blooms amid grasses_edited_edited_edited_edited_edited_edited_edited_edited

More threats

Havey's winter closure

​

The biologically rich Havey Canyon Trail is currently closed to cyclists from December 1 to March 1 to avoid washing mud and silt into Wildcat Creek. Havey Creek is the largest tributary to Wildcat Creek. Judging from muddy tracks and social media postings, cyclists routinely ignore this closure. It is unclear what trails would be used for bikers to go back up the hill once they descend the flow trail during Havey Canyon Trail’s seasonal closure. It is also unclear how the closure would be monitored and enforced, whether new or existing staff would be budgeted/deployed, and whether citations would be issued if there is a lack of compliance.

​

Lack of siting criteria

​​

Did the Park District apply objective siting criteria guidelines to identify the most suitable location within the Park District for the proposed Flow Trail? Did the Park District evaluate alternative sites as required by California environmental law? The answer to both questions is No, the Park District began with a biased location that was proposed from the outside. The Friends of Wildcat Canyon Park therefore developed its own Siting Criteria to ensure that EBRPD’s development planning for “mechanical and mechanized recreational activities,” e.g. mountain biking, avoids negative impacts to all park users, flora and fauna, and the underlying geological fabric so that the integrity of public lands is maintained. 

​

What about restrooms?

​

No restrooms are planned, suggesting human waste will end up in Wildcat Creek. Ideal locations for such a trail are accessible from a paved road, have large parking capacity, and proper infrastructure such as trash cans, drinking water, picnic tables, rest stops, and emergency access.

​

Special status species

 

Nowhere is conservation more important than on lands like Wildcat Canyon Park that have been untouched for generations of humans, except for limited trail use and grazing. The Park District’s consideration of this intensive cycling facility in Wildcat Canyon Park reveals a stunning lack of respect for the ecosystems that support Special Status Species, defined as “those that are rare, sensitive, or imperiled plants and animals needing special protection.” 

 

Wildcat Canyon’s “Potentially occurring species” include:

​

•  Alameda whipsnake (federally and State threatened species) - Nomad Ecology’s Biological Resource Assessment concedes that strikes by mountain bikers could result in whipsnake mortality.

•  California red-legged frog (federally threatened species and a California species of special concern)

•  White-tailed kite (California fully protected species)

•  Western pond turtle (California Species of Special Concern)

 

Both the Grasshopper Sparrow and the Purple Martin are designated as Birds of Special Concern by the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) due to significant declines, habitat loss, and range contraction, with Sparrows needing large, specific grassland habitats. Other listed species, i.e., bumblebees and a snail species, may be found in Nomad Ecology's report, pages 35-36, with an excellent map of species within a 5-mile radius of the flow trail on page 37. 

 

Santa Cruz tarplant is another federally threatened species and a California endangered species. For over 40 years, the EBRPD has collaborated with the USFWS and CDFW to manage introduced populations of the Santa Cruz tarplant in Wildcat Canyon to prevent extirpation of the species. According to Nomad Ecology, “The entire study area overlaps with critical habitat for the Santa Cruz tarplant.” And yet, the Park District does not plan to enforce the proposed closure of Leonard’s Trail, and the potential consequences to tarplant populations from mountain bike use could be devastating.

​

Impact of fenced areas

​​

The conceptual design includes 4 areas with barbed and smooth wire fencing with breaks between them. The gap between the trail and the fence is a minimum of ten feet. This is a narrow gap for an out-of-control cyclist to avoid becoming entangled in the fencing. This is even more unsafe for animals, should they enter the trail through the fencing or through those breaks. So-called “wildlife-friendly” fencing is poorly designed for winged predators, such as owls that fly at night. The latest edition of A Landowner’s Guide to Wildlife Friendly Fences (C. Paige, 2025)  suggests the use of white PVC tubing on the top wire. This may deter some of the owls and hawks, but it will introduce a jarring element into the landscape as the glaring white outline of the trail winds down the ridge, tracing the bulldozed path of the proposed trail. A. Jakes et al. (2018) point out that though fencing is a common landscape feature, “fence modifications to benefit multiple species must be tailored to the fence purpose, context, species present, and ecosystem.” The Park District has not carried out the studies that are needed to design appropriate fencing. (link to 040) The safety of cattle is at stake, too, as the rolling grate may pose a hazard to cattle, as well as deer and other animals that could get their hooves caught.

​

Dirt, silt, and microplastics

​

The soil geology in Wildcat Canyon Park is unstable and prone to liquefaction, which is the reason that it became parkland, rather than a residential development. Landslides in the 1970s and in 2016 underscored the wisdom of this approach. Construction of the proposed cycling facility will send silt downhill into Wildcat Creek with each winter’s rain. In addition, after the facility is completed, both silt and tire microplastics and any plastic-based soil stabilizers will be sent downhill, damaging the environment of the very fish that EBRPD is spending hundreds of thousands of public dollars to bring back to Wildcat Creek.

​

Destruction of natural beauty held for the public

​

The CEQA process evaluates potential changes to scenic views and vistas, as seen from public streets and viewpoints. The proposed trail will follow the general route of the Mezue hiking trail, swerving back and forth across the spine of the ridge. This is a major scenic view, as highlighted by the EBRPD.

​

Misuse of funds

​

Public funds derived from the Park District’s Measure WW are being used for planning this project, from staff time to subcontracts with Nomad Ecology for biological assessments, Pointe Strategies for trail design, and Ascent for the Environmental Impact Report. Those funds, however, were intended for land acquisition, not for capital construction projects.

​

EBRPD illogic

 

The official EBRPD position is that because the Mezue Trail is already being used by cyclists, the downhill, engineered intensive facility that would parallel the Mezue does not represent a new use and staff does not expect usage to increase. However, cyclists have presented petitions in support of the trail with over 2600 signatures, some of which were from out of state. We believe that such a trail will be extremely popular, and therefore a huge change from the current quiet and tranquil Mezue Trail.

​

Inadequate outreach and parking data

​

Members of Friends of Wildcat Canyon Park distributed leaflets to park users in the Summer of 2026. Over 80% of park users, including many neighbors of Wildcat Canyon Park, were ignorant of the EBRPD plan to build an intensive cycling facility. This demonstrates inadequate public outreach to the communities that live near the park. In addition, the Park District began to collect parking data after Labor Day of 2026, which may lead to an inaccurate estimate of use levels.

​

The costs don't add up

​

Park District staff (without knowledge of the Board) has spent thousands of hours of time on the proposed project without agendized public discussions at Board meetings. Following public disclosure of the plan, the EBRPD Board budgeted $250,000 for the first stage of an Environmental Impact Report. Construction costs are estimated at $280,000 to $390,000 by Pointe Strategies, but that does not include the cost of features, which range from $1208 for ladder drops to $18,481 for banked turns. Maintenance costs are likely to exceed $85,000 annually. Therefore this project is likely to cost substantially more than the $1 million donation at a time when the EBRPD budget is already strained. To date, there has been no public accounting.

​

Havey's winter closure
Lack of siting criteria
What about restrooms?
Special status species
Impact of fence areas
Dirt, silt, and microplastics
Distruction of natural beauty held for the public
Misuse of funds
EBRPD illogic
Inadequate outreach and parking data
The costs don't add up

Photo credits:

Mixed grasses - © 2026 Craig Noble 

​

bottom of page